Welcome back to Squat University! Last week we entered into Biomechanics 101, an introduction into the mechanics of the human body. We learned what torque is and how it is generated during the squat.
While the analysis from last week was a great starting point to understanding the squat, we can’t stop there. We need to take a deeper look at the 3 squat techniques and compare them realistically.
Biomechanics 101
Last week we compared torque as the rotational force of a wrench turning a bolt. This is what you feel at the shoulder when you try to hold a weight out in front of your body. This is a common illustration used by many professors in physics classes across the world. It is also common in strength & conditioning texts such as Mark Rippitoe’s book Starting Strength (2).
In order to calculate torque at a joint we need to know two things. First we need to know the length of the lever arm. In this illustration, this is the length between the point of rotation (the shoulder joint) and the line of force acting upon that joint (gravity pulling down the dumbbell). The length of the shoulder will therefore be the lever arm.
If we know the lever arm length and the angle of the joint we can find the moment arm (3). A longer moment arm will create more torque at a joint compared to a shorter moment arm (given the pull on the end of the lever is the same).
However, what we didn’t discuss was what happens when the pull on the lever changes. Torque can be manipulated by not only changing the length of the moment arm but also by changing the amount of force pulling down on the lever. When holding a 10 lb dumbbell out in front of your shoulder, there is roughly 44.5 Newton’s of force pulling down on your joint. This value represents the force of gravity’s acceleration acting upon the weight. In our illustration this created 33.4 Nm (Newton Meters) of torque at the shoulder joint. We came to this number by plugging in the length of the moment arm (.75meters or roughly 30 inches), the angle of the arm and the weight of the dumbbell.
The equation for torque at the shoulder looked something like this.
On the other hand, what if we now picked up a 20 lb dumbbell and tried to raise and hold it at the same extended position? This weight would then be converted to ~89 Newton’s of force. To get 89 Newton’s you must convert 20 lbs to 9.1 kg. This is then multiplied by 9.8 m/s2 (standard gravity acceleration) to end up with 89 Newton’s. If we assume the length of our arm didn’t change, the mathematical equation to calculate the new torque value would be:
Squat Analysis
Now that we know how torque can be manipulated by changing either the moment arm length and/or the amount of force pulling down on the lever, let’s now analyze the squat with weights that are more natural to each lift. A conservative estimate would be that an athlete can squat 15% more weight using a low-bar technique when compared to the high-bar technique. Most powerlifters use the low-bar variation over a high-bar back squat in competition for this reason. We could also make an educated guess and say most athletes could squat 15% more in the high-bar back squat compared to the front squat.
If we assume a 1 repetition maximum in the low-bar back squat to be 500 lbs, this would mean this individual could theoretically high-bar back squat 435 lbs and front squat around 378 lbs. Let’s see how the change in weight on the barbell changes the torque placed on the various joint complexes of the body.
Low-Bar Back Squat (500 lbs)
If we assume a lifter is capable of a 500 lbs low-bar back squat, this means there will be 2224.11 Newton’s of force now pulling down on the bar. This is a much larger value than we saw with the previous 225 lb loaded barbell.
For this analysis we will use the exact same lever arm lengths and joint positions from the previous illustration. We’ll again “freeze frame” the squat at the parallel position (hip crease in line with the knee) (4). The only thing that we’ll change will be the weight on the bar.
High-Bar Back Squat Analysis (435 lb)
Lets now see what happens when this athlete lifts 425 lb (1934.98 Newton’s) with the high-bar back squat. With this technique there is a more closed angle at the knee joint (now at 125° compared to the previous 120° with the low-bar technique). The angle at the hip joint will be at 55° which is more open when compared to the low-bar back squat hip angle of 40°.This is a normal change due to the more upright trunk position of this squat variation (4).
Front Squat Analysis (360 lbs)
Lastly, lets assume the same athlete now attempts to lift 378 lb (1681.43 Newton’s) with the front squat technique. The angles during the “freeze frame” at the parallel squat position will change again from the previous two techniques. The front squat uses a more closed angle of the knee joint (now at 130°). It also employs a more vertical trunk in order to keep the bar balanced on the chest and centered over the middle of the foot. This opens up the hip joint and low back to 75°.
Comparative Analysis (Varying Weights Across Techniques)
With this analysis we can see some striking differences compared to the last investigation that evaluated each squat at the same weight.
- The low-bar back squat technique placed dramatically more torque on the low back (lumbar/pelvis joint) and hip joint compared to the other techniques. In this parallel “freeze frame” analysis 717.7 Nm of force was applied to the low back and hip joint compared to the other techniques (522.4 Nm high-bar back squat and 403.5 Nm front squat). Comparatively, the low-bar squat placed 53% more torque on the hip and low back than the high-bar squat and 78% more than the front squat.
- The low-bar back squat however placed the least amount of torque on the knee joint compared to the other techniques!
- The high-bar back squat placed relatively the same amount of torque on the knee joint as the front squat. Despite having a longer moment arm in the front squat and a more closed angle, the heavier weight of the back squat increased knee torque to the same level.
Final Thoughts
As you can see with this analysis, changing the weight on the bar can significantly change the amount of torque that was generated on the different joint complexes. The smallest change in variables (weight on the bar, technique used, etc) can greatly change the forces placed on your body.
This allows us as coaches to make exercise recommendations for our athletes based on individual needs. For example, an athlete returning from a knee injury that can’t yet tolerate a more forward knee position during a barbell squat would benefit from using a low-bar back squat compared to a high-bar variation. This is in part because more torque is placed on the knee joint during the high-bar back squat.
Also, an athlete dealing with back pain may benefit from using a front squat during training instead of the conventional back squat. This is because the front squat places less torque on the low back compared to both back squat variations when more realistic weights are used. This recommendation is only practical if the injured athlete is able to perform the front squat with acceptable technique. An athlete with poor core control or restricted thoracic mobility may find it difficult to assume the form.
Exercise recommendations for healthy athletes exercise should not be based solely on the forces sustained at one joint. Research shows that healthy athletes can easily tolerate the forces for any of the 3 squat techniques (1). You shouldn’t worry about injuring the knee using high-bar or low-bar back squat. The ACL and other ligaments inside the knee joint should be completely safe. As long as good technique is used, joint stress values will never come close to exceeding harmful levels (1.).
Athletes should use a training program that employs multiple squat techniques to ensure a more balanced approach and to decrease risk of overuse injuries.
Until next time,
With
Resources
2) Rippetoe, M. (2011). Starting Strength. Basic barell Training. 3rd The Aasgaard Company. Wichita Falls, Texas.
Very interesting post!
Thanks!
I have almost all my life had a problem with the squat technique, although I learned about this problem recently. Special thanks for such a detailed description of the biomechanics of the process; I recently even read paperial reviews on EssayExplorer because I understood that I needed help with this science, but thanks to your post something became clearer. Not to mention the fact that now began to control the technique of his squats like never before.
A very interesting article. Joints are under enormous strain throughout life. Most problems in them are caused by the breakdown of the cartilage layer. As a result, the joint becomes inflamed and painful. Of course, many people have the question of how to save their joints, and people are looking for an answer to this question, and you too can find out when someone to write my papers on https://writemypapers4me.net/. At first, the pain occurs under exertion, then it becomes permanent and significantly worsens the quality of life. The prevention of some diseases and even injuries is to protect your joints properly and in good time.
A very interesting article. Joints are under enormous strain throughout life. Most problems in them are caused by the breakdown of the cartilage layer. As a result, the joint becomes inflamed and painful. Of course, many people have the question of how to save their joints, and people are looking for an answer to this question, and you too can find out when someone to write my papers on https://writemypapers4me.net/. At first, the pain occurs under exertion, then it becomes permanent and significantly worsens the quality of life. The prevention of some diseases and even injuries is to protect your joints properly and in good time.
Recently I turned to Papercoach.net for help with a paper I was writing and am so glad I did! Though initially skeptical of their legitimacy, now after experiencing their professional and reliable service first-hand I know they are indeed legit – no quality issues with the paper I received and an outstanding customer support team were all hallmarks of excellence – I would absolutely recommend Papercoach.net as a writing solution!
getaway shootout features a series of challenging and creative levels, each with its own set of obstacles and puzzles.
Fascinating analysis of torque in different squat techniques. It is eye opening to see how subtle variations in weight and form can significantly impact joint stress. Great insights for tailoring workouts to individual needs.
Comprehensive Glass Replacement in Marysville OH
When searching for a reliable calculator app, especially one adept at handling complex number patterns, prioritize those with robust mathematical capabilities. A number pattern calculator https://calculatorprofessional.com/number-sequence-calculator app should offer a range of functions, from basic arithmetic to advanced pattern recognition, ensuring it meets both everyday and specialized needs. Look for apps with high user ratings and reviews that highlight ease of use, accuracy, and a comprehensive set of features. Additionally, considering apps recommended by educational websites or forums can lead you to quality options tailored to mathematical exploration and learning.
LunwenHelp provides you with reliable and professional essay writing services https://www.lunwenhelp.com/essay-daixie/ to help you fulfill your academic needs and let you regain control of your life. All writer teachers are selected from the best teachers who have received more than 300 orders on their writing platform and have a reliable level and stable performance; to ensure that the quality of writing is invincible. For all non-urgent orders, the writing progress will be reported to the customer in a timely manner in the middle, so that the customer can be more relaxed.
i like part 2, it is very attractive @final grade calculator
Thanks a lot for the helpful information you bring. Hope you will always give everyone as many great posts as possible in the future.
io games
Our templates are ready to use straight away and can be customized to a plethora of different situations. From managing your personal affairs to creating study planners, we’ve got all the tools you need, and all completely https://templatecalendar.com/ free!
One thing I’ve noticed is how smooth the mobile experience is. Whether I’m playing on my phone or tablet, everything works perfectly without any glitches. El Royale makes it easy to pick up where I left off, which is so convenient when I’m on the go. I rarely feel limited by using a smaller screen.
The Real Science of the Squat Pt 2 breaks down the mechanics and benefits of perfecting your squat technique! Stay motivated during workouts with deezer premium, streaming your favorite high-energy playlists without ads!
After reading your post, I harvested a lot! I used to enjoy playing quordle game, but now I’ll study your posts and follow you to gain more knowledge.
Players must control limited resources including food, water, and tools because the Backrooms are shown as an unending maze.
Mental State: Extended Backrooms exposure to the unsettling setting causes psychological stress, which may cause the player to lose control of their sanity or go insane.
Offers a top-tier music streaming experience by granting access to premium features without a subscription. With over 90 million songs available, users can enjoy ad-free listening, offline playback, and high-resolution audio. The app also delivers personalized playlists and unlimited skips, creating a tailored experience for every user.
The exercise is not simple when my thigh muscles are very tight after the first 15 minutes of exercise. What should I do to stretch my muscles immediately after the pain? A quick exercise Uno Online Free will help me relieve this pain right on the spot, which is really great.
The modified Deezer Premium APK version appeals to users who want to enjoy the full features of Deezer without paying for a subscription. Especially in countries where premium plans are costly, these APKs become a popular alternative. It provides a taste of the full music streaming experience without financial commitment.
I didn’t think much of it when I first saw Football Plinko by BGaming. Just a casual game with a football skin, I figured — probably something I’d try once and forget about. But I was wrong. What I thought would be a throwaway experience ended up becoming a regular part of my gaming lineup, and honestly, it’s more fun than I ever expected.
The snow day calculator is a quick and easy tool that predicts the chances of school closures due to snow or icy weather. By entering your ZIP code, it analyzes local forecasts and gives a percentage-based estimate. It’s a helpful resource for parents, students, and teachers during the winter season.
You can play any game on our gaming center website without having to download anything or register.
Unblocked Games
bloodmoney 2 is a sequel that turns a simple clicker into a darker, guilt-ridden experience. In this game, every dollar you earn comes at Harvey’s expense.
Waise article bhi kaafi interesting tha, biomechanics aur torque wali example genuinely made sense. Funny thing is, the way you break down body mechanics reminds me of learning timing and strikes in Shadow Fight 2 — both need proper technique and control.
Good read overall. Looking forward to more posts like this!
https://shadowfighttwoapk.com/
Thank you so much for the helpful information you share.
Delta iOS update
I hope you continue providing everyone with many more great posts in the future. Delta Script
This kind of analysis helps improve both performance and injury prevention.